You are not logged in.


Hi,
I'm not sure if I can explain this correctly, let me try ....
On my XFCE panel from the latest MX Linux which was released earlier this year, when I place for example a thunar shortcut on the panel with an icon ... followed by clicking on that icon in order to open thunar, I then receive a second icon for the open application. In other words, then I have two icons on the panel instead of one. One icon for the app and one icon for the now open window belonging to that app.
Is there some setting which allows me to have the application icon as well as the open window that belongs to it, be shared, without creating additional clutter on the panel?
Helpful advice would be appreciated.
.
Last edited by SMXuser (Yesterday 11:09:46)
Offline


This is because MX has modified Xfce in such a bad way that I personally could not recognize it as XFCE until I read about it. Xfce (at least in Debian) normally has two panels, one starter panel at the bottom of your screen with icons to start applications, and a "system panel" at the top of your screen which contains the menu button, window buttons, workspaces and some system information icons. This design is very clear and obvious.
MX has messed up these two panels (or even created an own panel type) in such a way that you can't tell any item from the other. Very inconvenient and confusing if you are used to the two-panel design..
IMHO you can't blame XFCE for such a confusing design.
EDIT: Just to mention: The "duplicated" icon you see is part of the "window buttons". The window buttons app represents all the application windows that are currently open on the active workspace. It is a tool that allows you to switch between applications even if they are fullscreen, as long as you can see the panel. Things are easily misunderstood by MX's design.
Last edited by juribel (Yesterday 15:51:04)
Offline


Well I wasn't placing blame anywhere, just trying to figure things out.
So could I possible get things to work as I would like by simply adding my own third panel, modifying that every which way to contain anything that I want, to include the menu, internet connection, time/date, and so on .... followed by then deleting the default panel(s) which were on the default desktop after MX was installed?
Last edited by SMXuser (Yesterday 16:33:26)
Offline


Sorry, I did not mean to say that you were blaming anyone. Wrong vocabulary, I'm not an native English speaker :-)
As I installed MX and quickly desinstalled it when I saw it's appearance, I cannot tell if the MX panel is sort of modified Xfce panel or something else, MX specific. If it is a standard Xfce panel, you may try right click on the panel and go to the preferences. There you can add as many new panels as you like and configure them to your needs. It should be easy. There should be a lot of pre-installed items you can add to each panel including spacers (separator items). They can be configured visible or not, having a handle or not, being small or extend to fill rhe remaining space. If the panel is MX specific, there should also be a "panel" menu item in the Xfce standard system menu.
The Xfce menus can be horizontal or vertical, you can place them freely or fix them to any edge of your screen, you can have them automatically appear and disappear or having them always visible. Many many options...
Offline


So if I understood right, you want something akin to how Windows 7's (and up) taskbar works, i.e. you 'pin' an icon to it that's both a launcher and a task button?
I haven't used it much myself, but maybe you could try xfce4-docklike-plugin (not sure what the exact package name under Debian is, that's what it's called under Arch)? It's a panel plugin that sort of provides this functionality.
Nanos gigantum humeris insidentes.
Offline


In Xfce, a starter button is a starter button and a window button is a window button. These are separate panel items, but in MX you can't distinguish one from the other so that it looks like a clicked starter icon gets duplicated. It isn't. The "duplicate" is a separate item, a window button inside the "window button" app, invented to easily change focus between several currently active application windows.
Offline


A screenshot of what you're seeing would be helpful.
Some of the info provided above is incorrect.
MX hasn't modified Xfce to be unrecognisable or in a bad way, just different users prefer different setups.
I don't know of any way to use the launcher icon also as the window icon, I use the window buttons on a horizontal panel myself, though being Linux it could well be possible.
Perhaps asking on the MX forum might give you some options for getting it how you want it.
MX 25 defaults to the Docklike plugin for window/app icons once they're opened, not the window buttons plugin.
Probably that's what you're seeing, open a window or app and it'll show an icon in Docklike's location on the panel.
Docklike plugin can be removed via the panel preferences, Items tab, though I'm not sure what effect that would have on controlling the window or app, like when it's minimised etc..
Docklike can also be easily changed to the regular window buttons with MX Tweak, on the Xfce Panel tab under 'Tasklist'.
MX Tweak can back up the current panel config for you and it's easily restored if required.
I always make a backup of the current panel before changing anything.
Offline


So if I understood right, you want something akin to how Windows 7's (and up) taskbar works, i.e. you 'pin' an icon to it that's both a launcher and a task button?
I haven't used it much myself, but maybe you could try xfce4-docklike-plugin (not sure what the exact package name under Debian is, that's what it's called under Arch)? It's a panel plugin that sort of provides this functionality.
Thank you for all of the replies everyone. STJIMMY ... Yes, that's exactly what I'm talking about. I have a permanent symbol for a text editor, thunar, and so on, on the taskbar. If I decide to use both Thunar and the Text Editor at the same time, I click on them. Then instead of having four symbols on the panel, the open applications symply "take over" (for lack of better words) the two original symbols that were already there. That keeps the panel clean and streamlined, especially when there are 6 - 10 permanent app symbols on that panel.
I am very familiar with the panels and the panel settings which is why I mentioned creating new ones from scratch. I was hoping for a quick fix with less effort. Now I see that I'll have to pay a lot more attention to the MX25 panel since it's the first time that I've encountered it.
Offline
[ Generated in 0.012 seconds, 7 queries executed - Memory usage: 557.89 KiB (Peak: 574.48 KiB) ]